---
url: 'https://andrewjaffe.net/blog/2006/01/freak_chances_of_evolution_in_1/'
title: '&ldquo;Freak chances of evolution in an indifferent cosmos&rdquo;'
author:
  name: defjaf
  url: 'https://andrewjaffe.net/blog/author/andrewjaffe-net/'
date: '2006-01-07T23:38:04+00:00'
modified: '2006-01-07T23:38:04+00:00'
type: post
categories:
  - Science
tags:
  - Bunting
  - Channel 4
  - Dawkins
  - evolution
  - religion
  - The Root of All Evil
published: true
---

# &ldquo;Freak chances of evolution in an indifferent cosmos&rdquo;

In a criticism of Richard Dawkins’ upcoming series, [The Root of All Evil](http://www.channel4.com/culture/microsites/C/can_you_believe_it/debates/rootofevil.html), attacking religion, [Guardian columnist Madeleine Bunting](http://www.guardian.co.uk/Columnists/Column/0,,1681235,00.html) tries to find space leftover for, well, god:  “It’s also right for religion to concede ground to science to explain natural processes; but at the same time, science has to concede that despite its huge advances it still cannot answer questions about the nature of the universe — such as whether we are freak chances of evolution in an indifferent cosmos”.

Well, no.

Evolution, *per se*, says that our existence is indeed a freak chance in an indifferent cosmos. What it doesn’t tell us — because we don’t yet know enough about the origin of life here, let alone anywhere else — is whether life is common in the Universe, and if so, whether intelligence is a common result of evolution. But we, humanity, are indeed a contingent, freak occurrence. Any meaning that it may hold is up to us to impose.

I haven’t seen the show yet, but on the other hand I don’t think Dawkins’ shrill attacks on religion are particularly sensible — it’s a human institution like any other, and all institutions are as fallible as the people in them, irrespective of their so-called rationality. Again, it’s all in the meaning and the order that we impose on that “indifferent cosmos”.

