---
url: 'https://andrewjaffe.net/blog/2009/05/conditional_pro/'
title: Conditional Probability explained
author:
  name: defjaf
  url: 'https://andrewjaffe.net/blog/author/andrewjaffe-net/'
date: '2009-05-19T22:09:59+01:00'
modified: '2009-05-19T22:09:59+01:00'
type: post
categories:
  - Science
tags:
  - CSI
  - faith
  - probability
  - religion
published: true
---

# Conditional Probability explained

> Before it happened, I would have said slim. But since it happened, 100%.

 –Lawrence Fishburne, [CSI](http://www2.five.tv/programmes/drama/csi/), on the chances of being hit in the head by a tortoise dropped by a bird of prey.

(This goes well with [Ted Bunn’s exegesis](http://blog.richmond.edu/physicsbunn/2009/05/18/the-daily-show-on-probabliity-theory/) of the [Daily Show’s brief foray into probability theory](http://www.thedailyshow.com/video/index.jhtml?videoId=225921&title=Large-Hadron-Collider) for their segment filmed at CERN.)

I know this is a tired topic, but I am unable to resist using this as an opportunity to slag off [Stanley Fish’s idiotic attempt](http://fish.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/17/god-talk-part-2/index.html?ref=opinion) to equate “faith” in religion with “faith” in science. In both cases, we are talking about conditional probability, *P*(*hypothesis* | *information* ), which is read as “the probability of the *hypothesis* given the *information*“. I suppose that when the religious discuss “faith” in science, they are referring to the fact that something needs to go on the right side of the bar — all probabilities are conditional on something. But a crucial difference between religion and science is that the religious only put a couple of things on the right side: the words of a holy book (and don’t ask me why one should choose one book over another), or just the effects of some vaporous conversion experience which leaves all such probabilities as tautologies — god exists since I know god exists. For science, however, we get to condition our probabilities on, well, pretty much anything and everything. And the more we learn, the better it gets.

